New study reveals what it’s really like to be Black in politics

New study reveals what it’s really like to be Black in politics

When all the votes for the federal election are cast and counted, at least two of the nine Black sitting Members of Parliament (MPs) won’t return to their seats in the House of Commons.

Liberals Emmanuel Dubourg and former Minister for Women, Gender Equality and Youth, Marci Ien, aren’t seeking re-election.

Ien described the last few months of her time in government as “satisfying yet bittersweet” as she wrapped up her ministerial duties and said goodbye to the people she’s worked with for almost 5 years. Ien expressed her appreciation for Justin Trudeau’s role in her transition from journalist to politician.

“I don’t think anybody would have come to get me the way he did. He saw me as someone who could lead in a different way and frankly, I didn’t see that in myself,” Ien recalled.

Ien said it took several phone calls with members of the party and months of contemplation before she decided to run for office.

“I don’t want to be a politician, I interview them,” she told Trudeau’s former chief of staff Katie Telford. “This is not anything I ever hoped to be.”

According to a first-of-its-kind study conducted by Carleton University in partnership with Operation Black Vote Canada, Black on the Ballot, Ien’s experience of needing to be convinced to run for office is common among Black people.

The study examines what running for and serving in elected office is like using archival research, a national survey, and in-depth interviews with Black candidates and legislators to get details about their experiences.

The study also lists recommendations to encourage more Black people to seek elected office, including adopting a multi-pronged recruitment strategy and providing accessible candidate training, especially at the local level.

View full article
New study reveals what it’s really like to be Black in politics

Black on the Ballot tops Amazon Music’s list of election podcasts

Black on the Ballot tops Amazon Music’s list of election podcasts

Black on the Ballot tops Amazon Music’s list of election podcasts

Black on the Ballot tops Amazon Music’s list of election podcasts

Study finds Black Canadian politicians face systemic discrimination

Study finds Black Canadian politicians face systemic discrimination

A recent study reveals that most Black Canadians involved in politics face significant discrimination and barriers when trying to engage in government. Erin Tolley, the Canada Research Chair in Gender, Race, and Inclusive Politics and associate professor at Carleton University in Ottawa, authored Black on the Ballot: What Black Canadians Told Us About Running for and Serving in Elected Office.

Tolley’s research, which includes the first national survey of Black Canadians in politics alongside archival research, offers a comprehensive look at their inclusion in Canadian politics. “There really is not a lot of research on Black Canadians in politics,” Tolley noted, explaining that political scientists in Canada historically haven’t focused on race. “We tend to think of race as a concept more useful in the United States.”

One of the study’s key findings is the prevalence of negative experiences for Black Canadians entering politics. Of the 95 respondents to Tolley’s survey, 67 reported facing discrimination during their time running for office or while in office. More than half of them indicated that these discriminatory experiences occurred in public spaces or at their offices. These challenges, Tolley suggests, can have lasting effects on how long Black Canadians stay in politics.

View full article
Study finds Black Canadian politicians face systemic discrimination

Most Black Canadians taking part in politics face discrimination, study says

Most Black Canadians taking part in politics face discrimination, study says

Most Black Canadians participating in politics face discrimination and barriers to getting involved in government, according to a recent study.

Erin Tolley, who is a Canada Research Chair in Gender, Race and Inclusive Politics and associate professor at Carleton University in Ottawa, is the author of Black on the Ballot: What Black Canadians Told Us About Running for and Serving in Elected Office.

Her study involved a first-ever national survey of Black Canadians in politics and archival research to produce the most comprehensive account of their inclusion in Canadian politics, she said.

“There really is not a lot of research on Black Canadians in politics,” Tolley said. “Historically, political scientists have not thought about race in Canada. We tend to think race is a construct more useful in the United States.”

One of the key findings of Tolley’s work was how many Black Canadians experience negative reactions when entering politics.

Among the 95 people who responded to the survey, 67 said they had experienced discrimination while in office or running for office. More than half of these people said they were discriminated against while out in public or at their office.

These experiences can influence how long Black Canadians stay in politics, Tolley said.

View full article
Most Black Canadians taking part in politics face discrimination, study says

Black on the Ballot featured in The Conversation

Black on the Ballot featured in The Conversation

Twenty. That’s it. That’s the total number of Black Canadians ever elected to the House of Commons of Canada. There have been 372 Johns and 77 Jeans. You can easily find data on women parliamentarians, members of Parliament with military experience and even parliamentarians who have died in office. However, you’d be hard-pressed to find a complete list of Black Canadians in politics, never mind a comprehensive account of their experiences.

Because of their relative absence from accounts of Canada’s political history, Black Canadians’ contributions to politics are often overlooked or ignored. This erasure prevents governments, political parties, and researchers from crafting strategies to address political inequality.

When we lack relevant racial data on political candidacy and electoral outcomes, we can’t track progress or identify barriers. And when Black Canadians aren’t present in politics, public policies are less likely to reflect their circumstances and less responsive to their needs.

Groundbreaking new research from Carleton University and Operation Black Vote Canada aims to change that. Through archival research, a survey and more than 30 in-depth interviews, our report, Black on the Ballot documents the presence, backgrounds, motivations and experiences of Black Canadians in politics. Here’s what we found.

View full article
Black on the Ballot featured in The Conversation

black-canadians-in-electoral-politics-6

New research explores presence, experiences of Black Canadians in politics

A recently released, first-of-its-kind report is working to fill the research “gap,” and offer new insights and data on the experiences and numbers of Black Canadians who have run for public office.

“If you want to make change, you need to have an accurate picture of what is going on,” said project co-director Erin Tolley, an associate professor at Carleton University and Canada Research Chair in Gender, Race, and Inclusive Politics.

“Before now, we didn’t have great data on the number of Black Canadians that were running for and serving in office across all four levels of government, and that really prevents you from making research-based policy decisions, [and] from using evidence to try to figure out: is there a problem?”

By Laura Rykewaert  |  The Hill Times

View full article
black-canadians-in-electoral-politics-6

black-canadians-in-electoral-politics-event-carleton-university

Black on the Ballot Live Event - Carleton University

black-canadians-in-electoral-politics-event-carleton-university

By Karen Kelly

“The stories you hear tonight reflect a broader narrative about Black experiences in professional spaces and public life,” said Journalism Professor Nana aba Duncan, the evening’s moderator and director of the Mary Ann Shadd Centre for Journalism and Belonging. “What’s important is that this work moves us from being subjects of others’ stories to being the authors of our own narratives.”

The event, which took place Tuesday February 11, featured a panel discussion with Balarama Holness, the founder of Montreal in Action and Mouvement Montréal; Angela Simmonds, a former MLA and Nova Scotia’s first Black Deputy Speaker; and Garvia Bailey, co-founder of Media Girlfriends and producer of the Black on the Ballot podcast.

The event also included welcoming remarks from Carleton President Wisdom Tettey and Political Science Professor Erin Tolley, the Canada Research Chair in Gender, Race & Inclusive Politics.

Event Details

February 11, 2025

Live Event, Carleton University

Photos by Jaime Sadgrove

Prior to the panel discussion, Tolley shared highlights from her Black Canadians in Electoral Politics research report, which was drawn from “archival research, a national survey, and in-depth interviews with Black candidates and legislators.”

“The research report provides the most comprehensive account of Black Canadians’ experiences in politics that has ever been produced. It provides recommendations for increasing the number of Black Canadians who run for office and improving their experiences once they get there,” she said.

The findings of the report resonated with both Simmonds and Holness, who shared their experiences as politicians in Nova Scotia and Montreal, respectively.

Simmons shared the challenges she faced as a Black woman canvassing door-to-door, where she encountered racism from prospective voters. She also described the lack of support she received from her political party as the Deputy Speaker. Simmonds now heads a private firm that specializes in equity and inclusion in the workplace.

Holness described his efforts to bring Montreal’s disparate Black communities together as a candidate while also sharing a vision that extended beyond becoming Montreal’s “first Black mayor.” He recalled how, while his candidacy was focused squarely on reforming Montreal tax policy, major media outlets often ignored the issues he was campaigning on to highlight his race.

Both share their story on the Black on the Ballot podcast, which was produced by Garvia Bailey. She described her guiding principle to create a safe space for Black interviewees to share their stories honestly.

 

To learn more, listen to Black on the Ballot podcast here.

Read the Black Canadians in Electoral Politics research report here.

Story courtesy of Carleton University


black-canadians-in- electoral-politics-3

Here’s why Frank Baylis’s Barbadian roots matter

When you think of Black politicians, what names come to mind? Barack Obama? Kamala Harris? What about Frank Baylis? Baylis is one of five candidates running in the federal Liberal leadership race. He is an entrepreneur from Montreal, the son of an English father and Barbadian mother. He was elected to the House of Commons in 2015, handily winning his seat.

Citing a lack of respect and civility in politics, and a desire to spend more time on his business and with his family, he opted not to run in the 2019 election.

By Erin Tolley and Velma Morgan  |  The Gazette

View full article
black-canadians-in- electoral-politics-3

black-canadians-in-electoral-politics-event

Black on the Ballot: Centring Black Narratives in Public Life - A Black History Month Event

Inspired by Black on the Ballot, a new podcast and research report documenting the experiences of Black Canadians in politics, this panel will provide a critical look at the experiences of Black Canadians in politics, and the role of the journalists and researchers who chronicle their stories. Panelists will discuss how to increase the number of Black Canadians in public life and offer practical strategies for integrating Black perspectives into politics, journalism, and research.

Panelists:

  • Angela Simmonds, Former MLA & first Black Deputy Speaker in Nova Scotia
  • Balarama Holness, Founder of Montréal in Action & Mouvement Montréal
  • Garvia Bailey, Co-founder of Media Girlfriends & producer of Black on the Ballot
  • Erin Tolley, Lead researcher & Canada Research Chair in Gender, Race & Inclusive Politics at Carleton University

Moderator:

Nana aba Duncan, Director of the Mary Ann Shadd Cary Centre for Journalism and Belonging & host of Black on the Ballot

Opening Remarks:

Wisdom Tettey, President & Vice-Chancellor of Carleton University

Presented by:

The Carleton University School of Journalism and Communication and the Department of Political Science, with support from the Faculty of Public and Global Affairs, the Bell Chair in Canadian Parliamentary Democracy, the Canada Research Chair in Gender, Race and Inclusive Politics & the Mary Ann Shadd Cary Centre for Journalism and Belonging.

Event Details

Tuesday, February 11, 2025

Richcraft Hall, 2nd Floor Atrium
Carleton University


BOTB_Winning-is-Overrated

Winning is Overrated

Balarama Holness’ personal path to politics is unique. From growing up in an ashram, to a career as a professional football player, to running for mayor and founding a provincial political party. He became political, not necessarily to win, but to use the system to force change. How? In this conversation with host Nana aba Duncan, Balarama Holness talks about running for office and his conviction that, in politics, winning isn’t everything.

This episode features:

Balarama Holness
Candidate for Montréal-Nord borough mayor (2017), mayoral candidate for Montréal (2021), and provincial candidate for Bloc Montréal (2022)

Alvin Curling
Member of Ontario’s Provincial Parliament (1985-2005), speaker of the Legislative Assembly of Ontario (2003-2005), and Canada’s ambassador to the Dominican Republic (2005-2006)

This episode includes an audio clip from CTV’s W5.

Resources for this episode:

Read the research that supports this podcast:

New report on being Black in Canadian politics

On Black Canadians’ voter turnout:

Statistics Canada’s data on voter turnout by racial background

On abuse in local politics:

Samara Centre for Democracy’s SAMbot Municipal Report

To support the important work being done by Operation Black Vote Canada, consider making a donation.

BOTB_Winning-is-Overrated

Listen on your favourite streaming channel

Apple

Spotify

YouTube

Amazon

Download transcript

Follow the podcast on Instagram